Photo editing · 7 min read ·

Photo Restoration Services vs AI: Cost and What to Expect

Online photo restoration services such as FixThePhoto, MemoryCherish, MSW Print and ScanMyPhotos charge $30 to $60 per photo at most tiers, up to $148 for a senior artist, plus extras such as $19.95 to colorize. Delivery takes 1 to 20 days. AI tools cost a few dollars or less and finish in minutes, but they invent missing detail, so pay a person for damaged faces and one-of-a-kind heirlooms.

Photo restoration services are retouchers who repair a scanned photo by hand and send back a clean digital file, usually for a set price per photo. AI tools do a similar job in minutes for much less, but they fill missing detail with a guess, where a person can ask you or work from another photo. Below are what four online services charge and how long they take, the software and apps in between, and how to decide which route a particular photo deserves.

What photo restoration services do

A photo restoration service is a retoucher, or a team of them, who repairs a digital copy of a damaged photo in image editing software and returns the improved file. Most old photo restoration services work the same way. You upload a scan, or mail the print to be scanned, describe what bothers you, and receive a restored image, often with a round of revisions. FixThePhoto's steps, for example, are to upload the photos, write your recommendations, submit for revision if needed, and get the photos back.

What gets fixed depends on the tier you pay for. FixThePhoto's Standard level covers light scratches, sepia problems, dull colors and small damaged areas. Its Premium level adds medium scrapes and missing parts, and Extreme adds deep damage, ruined edges, merging photos and colorizing. ScanMyPhotos sells one base restoration and lists extras separately, from cropping to teeth whitening.

A restoration service fixes the image, not the object. If the print itself has mold, is flaking, or is stuck to an album page, that is a job for a photograph conservator, and the Library of Congress points people to the American Institute for Conservation's directory to find one.

Photo restoration services vs AI at a glance

Question Professional service AI tool Software you run yourself
Cost per photo $30 to $60 at most tiers, up to $148, at the services priced here Under a dollar to a few dollars in credits, or a subscription Free (GIMP, Snapseed) to US$22.99 a month (Photoshop)
Turnaround About 1 to 3 days at MemoryCherish, 20 days at ScanMyPhotos' standard price Seconds per edit: a few for MyHeritage In Color, about 30 for Toybox image tools As long as your skill and patience allow
Missing faces or features Rebuilt by a person, who can work from other photos Invented by the AI Rebuilt by you
Changes after delivery Revisions, depending on the service Run it again with a new instruction Undo and redo
Your original print Stays home if you upload a scan Stays home Stays home
Best for Heirlooms, heavy damage, faces Fading, specks, blur, colorizing for fun Many photos, if you'll learn the tools

What professional photo restoration services cost

As of September 2026, these four online photo restoration services publish their prices, and each sets them a different way: by damage, by artist, by quantity, or at a flat rate.

Service and tier Price per photo How the price is set
FixThePhoto Standard $30 Light scratches, dull colors, color correction, small damaged areas, up to 3 people
FixThePhoto Premium $45 Standard plus medium scrapes and missing parts
FixThePhoto Extreme $60 Premium plus deep damage, ruined edges, merging and colorizing
MemoryCherish Experienced, Head or Senior Artist $38, $58 or $148 You pick the artist level, and the damage doesn't change the price
MSW Print $45 for one, $37.50 each for two, $30 each for three or more Quantity; digital files only
ScanMyPhotos restoration $45.50 One flat price, with 20-day completion
ScanMyPhotos rush $54.50 or $75.50 The same work in 10 days or 3 days

The extras add up quickly. FixThePhoto charges $12 for each person beyond three. At ScanMyPhotos, colorizing adds $19.95, eye retouching adds $34.50 per person, removing up to three small objects adds $9.95, and removing up to three large elements adds $82.50. ScanMyPhotos also says no discounts or promo codes apply to restoration work. MemoryCherish shows the cost of add-ons such as colorizing before you order.

For a batch, multiply before you order. Restoring 20 photos at ScanMyPhotos' standard price is $910, at MemoryCherish's Experienced Artist level it's $760, and at FixThePhoto's Standard level or MSW Print's three-plus price it's $600. At those prices, it makes sense to try AI or software on the easy photos first and send only the hardest ones to a person.

Photo restoration software and apps

Photo restoration software and apps sit between paying a person and a one-tap AI tool, and most of them cost little or nothing.

  • GIMP is free for Windows, macOS and Linux, and its source code is open. Hand retouching and hand colorizing are possible, but you learn the tools yourself.
  • Snapseed is Google's free photo editing app, with a Healing brush for specks and White Balance for faded color.
  • Google Photos has one-tap Enhance and a free Unblur tool on Android 8.0 and iOS 18 phones that have at least 3 GB of RAM.
  • Adobe Photoshop is US$22.99 a month alone or US$19.99 a month in the Photography plan with Lightroom, both on annual plans billed monthly, with a 7-day free trial.
  • MyHeritage's Reimagine app colorizes, enhances, animates and repairs family photos, and scans album pages. A few photos are free, then it costs $7.99 a month or $49.99 a year.

The step-by-step methods for the free tools are in the guide to restoring faded and torn photos, and MyHeritage is compared with other apps in the MyHeritage Photo Enhancer alternatives.

When a professional is worth paying for

  • A face is torn, missing or stained. AI tools fill the gap with features that never existed. A restorer can rebuild an eye from another photo of the same person, and ask you before guessing.
  • It's the only copy of an heirloom. For $30 to $60 at most tiers, a person can check with the family before rebuilding a face, which no AI tool does.
  • The damage is extensive. Deep damage, ruined edges and several torn pieces are what FixThePhoto's top tier exists for.
  • Several people in the photo need care. Every face in a group portrait has to be checked, which is why FixThePhoto prices each person beyond three.
  • You want corrections from a person. A service that takes revisions lets you say "her hair was darker" and get it changed. MemoryCherish, for one, says its revisions are free until the result is right.

When an AI tool is enough

  • Fading and color casts. These are the easiest fixes, and free apps often handle them alone.
  • Dust, specks and light scratches. A healing brush or an AI tool clears them without inventing much.
  • A slightly soft photo. AI sharpening can help, as long as you compare the faces with the original afterward.
  • Colorizing for a slideshow or a group chat. Colors are a guess either way, as the colorizing how-to shows. MyHeritage says its colorizer can get clothing colors wrong, and a person colorizing by hand has the same problem without family records.
  • Dozens of photos. At Toybox AI's current prices, colorizing 50 photos in Image Colorizer is 3,750 credits, which a 5,000-credit top-up at $46.99 covers. At ScanMyPhotos, where colorizing is a $19.95 add-on to the $45.50 restoration, the same 50 photos would be $3,272.50.

How to choose the best photo restoration services

The best service for your photo is the one whose pricing matches the damage and whose terms you've checked. Before you pay, confirm these:

  • Samples of similar damage. Look for before and after examples of tears or stains like yours, not only faded color.
  • How the price is set. A damage-based tier (FixThePhoto) rewards an honest description of the damage. An artist-based price (MemoryCherish) stays the same however bad the tear is. A quantity price (MSW Print) favors ordering several photos at once.
  • How many people are included. Group photos can cost more per extra face.
  • Turnaround and rush fees. Standard and rush times can differ by weeks.
  • Upload or mail-in. Uploading your own scan keeps the original at home. Scan wallet-size and 4 x 6 prints at 600 ppi, the top level in the Federal Agencies Digital Guidelines Initiative's guidelines for photographic prints.
  • Revisions and refunds. Ask how many rounds are included and how to request them. MemoryCherish, for example, advertises a 30-day money-back guarantee.
  • The file you get back. Ask for the file format and pixel size, and keep your untouched scan alongside it.

One damaged portrait, four ways

Take a hypothetical 5 x 7 inch black and white wedding portrait from the late 1940s, with a tear across the background, a crease through the groom's sleeve, both faces intact, and a family that wants it in color.

  • ScanMyPhotos: $45.50 for restoration plus $19.95 for colorizing is $65.45, done in 20 days. The 3-day ultra rush makes it $95.45.
  • FixThePhoto: the tear and the colorizing point to the Extreme level at $60 for the two people.
  • MemoryCherish: $38 at the Experienced Artist level whatever the damage, plus the colorizing charge it shows before you order, usually delivered in 1 to 3 days.
  • Toybox: on a Pro plan, two Smart Editor edits for the tear and the crease are 170 credits in HD, and Image Colorizer adds 75, for 245 credits. That's about $2.45 at top-up prices, but Smart Editor needs Pro, which currently starts at $9.99 a month for 1,000 credits (see pricing). The photo restoration prompts include instructions for a tear and a crease.

Whichever route you pick, compare the faces with the original scan at full size before anyone prints it. If a face had been torn, a human restorer would be the safer choice.

Try the AI route first in Image Colorizer

For a faded or black and white photo without serious damage, try Image Colorizer in Toybox before you pay for a service. Add the scan under "Your photo", write the colors you know in "Notes" under "More options", and tap "Colorize photo". It currently costs 75 credits on the Free plan and adds color only, so for tears and stains use Smart Editor (Pro plan) first, as the steps in how to restore old photos with AI show. If the result still isn't right after a try or two, that photo is the one to send to a person.

Frequently asked questions

How much do photo restoration services cost?

At the four online services priced here, most photos cost $30 to $60. FixThePhoto charges $30, $45 or $60 by damage level, MemoryCherish $38, $58 or $148 by the artist you choose, and MSW Print $45 for one photo or $30 each for three or more. ScanMyPhotos charges $45.50, plus $19.95 to colorize and $34.50 per person for eye retouching.

Are photo restoration services online safe for my original prints?

The safest option is to keep the print at home. ScanMyPhotos' restoration order asks for an uploaded image, MSW Print restores digital files only, and MemoryCherish takes a phone snapshot or a mailed original, which it says travels tracked and insured and comes back free. Afterward, store the print in photo-safe enclosures at 30 to 50% relative humidity and 70°F or below, as the Library of Congress recommends.

How long does professional photo restoration take?

MemoryCherish says most restorations take about 1 to 3 days. At ScanMyPhotos, standard restoration takes 20 days for $45.50, rush takes 10 days for $54.50, and ultra rush takes 3 days for $75.50. AI tools return a result much faster. Most Toybox image tools finish in about 30 seconds, though you may run several edits before you're happy.

Can AI photo restoration match a professional restorer?

For fading, dust and light scratches, an AI tool's result can be good enough to keep once you've checked it at full size. For a missing or stained face, it isn't a fair comparison, because AI fills the gap with invented features while a restorer can work from other photos of the same person and take your corrections. Judge the result against the original, not against a sample.

Who can fix the physical photo, not just the scan?

A photograph conservator. Restoration services return an improved digital file, while a conservator treats the print itself, for problems like mold, flaking or photos stuck together. The American Institute for Conservation's Find a Professional directory lists conservators by specialty, including Photographic Materials, and by location.

Sources

Make it with AI Image Colorizer

Keep reading